If you’re shopping for the best freestanding natural gas grill, you probably already know what you don’t want. You don’t want a grill that cooks burgers with a hot center and cold edges, rusts out in three summers, or charges you for features you’ll never use.
I’m Andy, and I’ve spent more than a decade cooking on gas, charcoal, and smokers. I’ve seen what good and bad grill design does to a cookout, whether it’s a Sunday brisket or forty burgers for a birthday party. A grill is a long-term purchase, so I’d rather you pick one you’ll enjoy for years than the one with the most burners or the biggest BTU number on the box.
Here’s how I put this guide together. I haven’t cooked on every grill below, and I won’t pretend I have. The recommendations come from manufacturer specs, documented features, warranty terms, and the patterns that show up again and again in owner feedback. I bring my own cooking experience to explain what those specs mean when you’re standing at the grill with a pile of chicken thighs and a hungry family.
Three questions come up constantly, so let’s answer them up front:
Natural gas has real appeal. You never run out of fuel halfway through a cookout, you never haul a tank to be refilled, and a freestanding cart gives you shelves, storage, and room to work. The trade-off is that the best grill for you depends on your space, your budget, how you cook, and whether you have a natural gas line (or can add one). Let’s find yours.
If you’re ready to buy, start here. I’ve listed cooking area and burner count because the physical size of the grate usually decides whether a grill fits your life. Figures are approximate and vary by model year, so confirm them on the retailer’s page before you buy.
| Award | Grill | Burners | Cooking Area (approx.) | Best For | Price Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Weber Genesis E-325s NG | 3 + Sear Zone | ~513 sq in primary | Most backyard cooks | Midrange–premium |
| Best Value | Weber Spirit II E-310 NG | 3 | ~424 sq in primary | Smart spenders | Midrange |
| Best Under $500 | Dyna-Glo 4-Burner Open Cart NG | 4 | ~500+ sq in primary | Strict budgets | Budget |
| Best Small Grill | Weber Spirit E-210 NG | 2 | ~360 sq in primary | Patios and decks | Budget–midrange |
| Best for Large Backyards | Napoleon Rogue SE 525 RSIB NG | 4 + infrared side and rear burners | ~525 sq in primary | Big crowds | Midrange–premium |
| Best Premium | Napoleon Prestige PRO 500 NG | 4 + infrared side and rear burners | ~500 sq in primary | Serious cooks | Premium |
| Best with Side Burner | Broil King Baron 490 NG | 4 + side burner + rotisserie burner | ~625 sq in primary | Full outdoor kitchen cooking | Midrange–premium |
A note on prices and availability: Prices move, and grills go in and out of stock. Before you click “buy,” confirm the listing says natural gas in the title or specs. Most of these brands sell the same grill in propane and natural gas versions with different model numbers, and ordering the wrong one is the most common and most annoying mistake in this category. Good grills tend to sell through quickly during spring and the pre-summer rush, so if you’ve found your match, don’t wait until the week of your first cookout to order it.
Best for: Most backyard cooks who want one grill to do everything well.
If a friend asked me for one grill that would handle burgers on Tuesday, steaks on Friday, and a full spread on Sunday, this is the one I’d point to. The Genesis has been the mid-range benchmark for years, and the reasons are practical.
What it offers:
Why the Sear Zone matters: Most gas grills do a decent job cooking and a mediocre job searing. A good steak needs a ripping hot surface to build a crust, and a dedicated sear burner is a big help there. Without one, you end up leaving the lid open and hovering, hoping the grates get hot enough. With one, you can sear a thick ribeye hard, then slide it to a cooler zone to finish while you deal with everything else.
Heat control: Weber’s burner and flavorizer bar design is built to spread heat evenly and cut flare-ups. Even heat means fewer burned edges and raw middles, and it makes direct and indirect cooking predictable. With three burners, you can leave one side off and cook chicken thighs gently while burgers sear on the other. That kind of control is what separates a grill you fight with from one you trust.
A real-world scenario: Picture a Saturday with bone-in chicken, corn, and a couple of steaks for the neighbors. On a grill like this, the chicken goes on the cooler side with the lid down, the corn sits at the edge, and the steaks hit the sear zone for the last few minutes. Everything finishes around the same time, and you’re not juggling.
Who should skip it: If you grill a couple of times a month and mostly cook hot dogs, the Genesis is more grill than you need. The Spirit II below will serve you just as well for less money.
Honest drawbacks:
Andy’s verdict: The Genesis is for the person who wants to buy once and stop thinking about grills. The build, the parts support, and the sear capability make it a strong long-term choice. If you can stretch your budget here, you’ll likely be glad you did.
[Check Price at Amazon] | [Check Price at an Authorized Retailer]
Best for: Buyers who want solid performance and long-term durability without the Genesis price tag.
The best value grill isn’t the cheapest one. It’s the one that gives you the most useful performance per dollar and doesn’t fall apart in year three. The Spirit II E-310 is a very good example.
What it offers:
Where the savings come from: Compared with the Genesis, you get fewer frills: no dedicated sear station, a bit less cooking area, and a simpler cart. For most weeknight cooking, you won’t miss any of that.
Essentials vs. extras: Think about what you actually do with a grill. If it’s burgers, chicken, sausages, vegetables, and the occasional steak, the Spirit II covers it. Spending more mostly buys you extra capacity, a sear station, and nicer finishes. Those are real improvements, but they aren’t necessities. Ask yourself honestly how often you’d use them. If the answer is “a few times a year,” keep the difference in your pocket.
Maintenance: Expect to brush the grates after each cook, empty the grease tray regularly, and give the burners an occasional inspection. Weber’s design makes these chores easier than most. A grill that’s easy to clean is a grill you’ll actually clean, and that’s what keeps flare-ups and rust at bay.
Who should skip it: If you regularly cook for big groups, or you’re a dedicated steak person who wants a seriously hot sear, step up to the Genesis or the Napoleon Rogue.
Honest drawbacks:
Andy’s verdict: This is the grill I’d recommend to most people asking me what to buy. It’s a dependable all-rounder with a strong support network, and it sits at a sensible price for what you get. Would spending more get you a meaningful upgrade? Only if you need the extra space or the sear power.
[Check Price at Amazon] | [Check Price at an Authorized Retailer]
Best for: Buyers who need a real natural gas grill on a firm budget.
I’m going to be straight with you: the best freestanding natural gas grill under $500 is a tricky category. Many manufacturers make plenty of cheap propane grills, but the factory-built natural gas versions often cost more. Entry-level NG grills commonly start above $500, and prices swing with sales and stock.
The Dyna-Glo 4-Burner Open Cart (model DNG405SNP-D) is one of the few factory natural gas options that regularly lands near this budget.
What it offers:
Treat $500 as a real limit. Before you buy, check the current price and confirm the listing is the natural gas model. If the grill is only under $500 on a lucky sale and is $560 the rest of the time, you need to know that going in. If it’s over your limit when you check, don’t let that push you toward a propane grill you’ll later have to convert.
What you give up:
Stretching the budget: If you can find another $100 to $150, look hard at the Weber Spirit II. You’d gain better heat management, stronger support, and a grill that can reasonably be expected to outlast a budget model. That isn’t a push. It’s what I’d tell a friend over the fence. But if $500 is a hard ceiling, this is a sensible place to land.
Who should skip it: If you plan to keep the grill for ten years and cook on it several times a week, spend more. A better-built grill costs less per year of use.
Andy’s verdict: For occasional to moderate grillers on a tight budget, this is a sensible way to get natural gas without a huge outlay. Just go in with eyes open. You’re saving money on materials, and a cover plus regular cleaning is the best way to protect that savings.
[Check Price at Amazon] | [Check Price at an Authorized Retailer]
Best for: Small patios, decks, townhouse backyards, and smaller households.
Plenty of people buy a bigger grill than they need. Then it eats half their patio, burns more gas to preheat, and cooks the same food they would have cooked on something smaller.
What it offers:
Heat zones: Two burners give you a basic two-zone setup. Turn one off, and you can cook indirectly on that side. It isn’t as flexible as a three- or four-burner grill, but it’s enough for chicken, sausages, and thick chops. For a couple or a small family, that’s most of what you cook on a weeknight.
Limits to know about: If you regularly host groups of eight or more, you’ll be cooking in batches. That’s fine for a quiet family dinner, but it gets old at a party. A compact grill also won’t hold a big rack of ribs or a large roast comfortably.
Measure the whole footprint. Look at the cart and shelves, not just the grate. Add clearance around the grill for safety, and think about where your gas line comes out. A natural gas grill can’t wander around the yard, so the spot you pick is the spot it lives in.
Who should skip it: If you entertain regularly or cook for a big family, go with the Spirit II E-310 or larger.
Andy’s verdict: If you have limited outdoor space, this is a smart pick. It gives you real Weber build quality and a natural gas connection without taking over your deck.
[Check Price at Amazon] | [Check Price at an Authorized Retailer]
Best for: Big families, regular entertainers, and people who like cooking several things at once.
If you’re the person who ends up cooking for the whole neighborhood, you need space and flexibility, and that’s what the Rogue SE 525 is built for.
What it offers:
Why infrared matters: Infrared burners get extremely hot, extremely fast. For steaks, that means a quick, deep crust. A rear rotisserie burner heats a spinning chicken or roast evenly from behind, which is a lovely way to cook a whole bird with crisp, even skin.
Zones for a crowd: Four burners let you set up several zones at once: sear steaks on one side, cook sausages on medium, and keep finished food warm on the other. When fifteen people are waiting on food, that flexibility keeps you from feeling like a short-order cook.
Size and stability: This is a big grill. Check the cart footprint, make sure the surface is level, and consider the weather exposure where it will live. A cover is a must.
Is the extra size worth it? If you regularly cook for more than six people, yes. If you mostly cook for two to four, you’ll be paying for capacity you rarely use.
Honest drawbacks:
Andy’s verdict: For big backyards and bigger gatherings, this grill has the muscle and the options to keep you from running out of space. If your cookouts keep growing, this is the grill that will grow with you.
[Check Price at Amazon] | [Check Price at an Authorized Retailer]
Best for: Serious backyard cooks who want top-tier construction and features.
The Prestige PRO 500 sits at the top of this list, and it’s priced accordingly. So the question is whether the upgrades justify the premium.
What it offers:
The upgrades that matter:
The upgrades that are nice but not necessary: Illuminated knobs and fancy finishing look great, but they won’t make your chicken taste better.
Who should buy it: If you grill several times a week, plan to keep the grill for a decade or more, and care about build quality and features, this is a grill that can justify its price. Spread over ten or fifteen years of regular use, the cost per cookout drops quickly.
Who should skip it: If you cook a few times a month, the money is better spent elsewhere. The Genesis or Spirit II will give you most of what you need.
Honest drawbacks:
Andy’s verdict: This is the “buy it for life” pick. It’s a lot of money, but if grilling is a real hobby for you, this is the grill that rewards that enthusiasm.
[Check Price at Amazon] | [Check Price at an Authorized Retailer]
Best for: People who want to cook whole meals outdoors.
A good side burner means you can make barbecue sauce, sauté onions and peppers, or boil corn without running back and forth to the kitchen.
What it offers:
Practical uses for the side burner:
A real-world scenario: Say you’re doing ribs and a pot of baked beans for a gathering. The ribs cook indirectly on the main grill, the beans simmer on the side burner, and you’re never leaving the party to check the stove. That’s the whole appeal.
Does it earn its keep? If you cook full meals outdoors, absolutely. If you mostly just grill meat and eat it with sides made inside, a side burner is a feature you’ll use rarely.
Honest drawbacks:
Andy’s verdict: If outdoor cooking is a full-meal experience for you, this grill’s versatility is the draw. If not, put that money toward better construction or more cooking area.
[Check Price at Amazon] | [Check Price at an Authorized Retailer]
With the picks out of the way, here’s how to match a grill to your own situation. Read this section before you check prices, and you’ll be a much more confident buyer.
Think about how many people you usually cook for, and about your biggest typical cookout.
Also consider the entire cart, shelves open and closed, not just the grate. And don’t buy more grill than you need. Bigger grills use more gas and take longer to preheat. A good rule of thumb is to size for your regular week, not your once-a-year party. You can always cook in batches for the party.
Multiple burners let you set up direct heat (food over the flame) and indirect heat (food off to the side). That’s the difference between searing a steak and slowly cooking a whole chicken.
Burner count alone doesn’t tell you much. A well-designed three-burner grill can outperform a poorly built five-burner one. Look for even heat distribution and responsive controls, and be wary of any grill whose main selling point is a big burner count.
Material quality, thickness, and manufacturing matter more than appearance. Lift the lid, feel the weight, and look at how the firebox is put together. If you’re ordering online, read what owners say about rust, warped parts, and burner failures after a year or two.
BTUs measure how much fuel a burner can burn per hour. They are not a direct measure of cooking performance.
A grill with a huge BTU number can still cook unevenly if the heat distribution is poor or the grill leaks heat. What counts:
You’ll appreciate these features more with each cookout:
Grease management is the one I’d never skip. Grease buildup causes flare-ups and fires, and a design that sends grease cleanly to a tray you can actually reach saves you a lot of trouble.
Don’t just look at the headline warranty. Check:
A good grill cover is one of the cheapest ways to protect your investment.
Your grill must be built or manufacturer-approved for natural gas. Beyond that, you need:
Quick-disconnect fittings and sizing: Natural gas quick-disconnect fittings and hoses commonly come in 3/8″ and 1/2″ sizes. A longer hose run, or a grill with a high total BTU output, may need a larger-diameter gas line to deliver enough gas. If the line is undersized, the grill can run weak, especially when all burners are on. A qualified gas fitter can size the line properly for your grill and the distance from the meter. Mention the grill’s total BTU rating when you call, since that’s what they’ll need.
Safety note: Never connect a propane grill directly to natural gas. Conversion should only be done when the manufacturer explicitly supports it for your exact model, using approved components and qualified installation where required.
A few extras make setup smoother and save you a frustrating second trip to the store:
Budget a little for these when you plan your purchase, so the grill you buy is ready to cook the day it arrives.
This is the decision that can save you from buying the wrong grill, so it’s worth a minute.
| Feature | Natural Gas | Propane |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel supply | Connected to a gas line | Supplied from a tank |
| Refilling | No tanks to refill | Tank needs refilling or swapping |
| Initial setup | May require gas-line installation | Needs a compatible tank and regulator |
| Mobility | Limited by the gas connection | Highly flexible |
| Running costs | Often lower per unit of energy | Varies with local propane prices |
| Best for | Permanent backyard setups | Flexible setups without a gas line |
Often, yes, especially if you grill a lot. But the installation cost and your local fuel prices affect the total. If you already have a gas line on your patio, the savings are easier to capture. If you’d need to run a new line, add that cost to your math before deciding.
A well-designed grill can cook excellently on either fuel. Performance comes down to engineering, burner design, and heat control, not the fuel type. Don’t let anyone tell you natural gas cooks worse. A good grill is a good grill.
My take: Natural gas is a great fit for frequent grillers who already have a connection and plan to keep their grill in one spot. If you move often or don’t have a line, propane may be the more practical choice.
Whichever grill you choose, a few habits will add years to its life:
None of this takes long, and it’s what separates a grill that lasts a few seasons from one that lasts a decade or more.
It depends on your budget, space, and cooking style. For most people, the Weber Genesis E-325s is my top pick for overall performance and long-term value.
The Weber Spirit II E-310 offers a strong balance of build quality, performance, and price.
You can, but options are limited. Make sure the model is sold in a natural gas configuration at that price. The Dyna-Glo 4-Burner is one of the more realistic choices, but expect trade-offs in build quality and features. Confirm the current price first.
The Weber Spirit E-210 offers a compact footprint, fold-down shelves, and dependable heat.
Neither is universally better. Natural gas favors convenience for a fixed setup, while propane offers mobility.
Only if the manufacturer explicitly supports conversion for your exact model, using approved parts and proper installation. Don’t improvise this.
Two to three burners suit most households, and four or more suit larger cooking surfaces. Heat distribution and cooking area matter just as much as burner count.
It depends on construction, weather exposure, maintenance, and parts availability. A well-built grill that’s covered and cleaned regularly can last many years, but no one can promise a specific number.
What to do next: Pick the grill that matches your space, your budget, and the way you actually cook. Then compare current prices, confirm you’re ordering the natural gas version, and get your gas line sorted. Do that, and you’ll be cooking on a grill you’ll enjoy for years. Your first cookout is closer than you think.
By Andy | Barbecuemen.com Disclosure: Barbecuemen.com may earn a commission if you buy through links…
By Andy, Barbecuemen.com I've lost count of how many folding grills I've unboxed over the…
By Andy | Last updated: November 2026 | Prices checked: November Disclosure: Barbecuemen.com is reader-supported.…
By Andy, Barbecuemen.com Last summer I watched a guy at a lakeside campsite wrestle…
By Andy, backyard pitmaster at BarbecueMen Affiliate disclosure: Some links below are affiliate links. If…
By Andy, backyard pitmaster at BarbecueMen.com I've lost count of the briskets, pork butts, and…